More police arrived within minutes, and a Geiger counter was
produced. As Makeria smoked nervously in the back seat, the officers
flipped the instrument's "on" switch and watched the needle leap off
the screen.
"At first we were just shocked," Maj. Leri Omiadze, the ranking
officer at the scene, recalled later. "Then we all started backing
away slowly."
Inside Makeria's boxes were two capsules of highly radioactive
metals -- strontium and cesium -- of a type that terrorism experts
say can be used in a dirty bomb, a device that spews radiation but
does not trigger a nuclear explosion. A third container held a vial
of brown liquid that Georgian police identified as the substance
used in mustard gas, one of the earliest chemical weapons. Only
later did police learn Makeria's role in the affair. He was a
courier for criminals trading in components and materials for
weapons of mass destruction.
In a scheme still not fully understood, the boxes were delivered
to Makeria by another Georgian, a man with a history of drug
offenses. Makeria's job was to carry the boxes by train from Tbilisi
to Adzharia province, a troubled enclave on Georgia's southwestern
frontier. From there, police believe, they were to be transported by
other couriers across the border into Turkey or perhaps even Iran,
for delivery to an expectant customer. The buyer's identity remains
unknown.
What is certain is that the Georgians who sought to profit from
selling components of a dirty bomb are far from unique.
There have been dozens of cases of trafficking in radiological
materials over the past three years, along with what some weapons
experts describe as a disturbing new trend. While most sellers of
such materials have traditionally been amateurs -- opportunists and
lone actors in search of easy profits -- authorities are now seeing
a surge of interest among criminal groups. In a string of incidents
from the Caucasus and Eastern Europe to West Africa and South
America, gangs have stalked and stolen radiological devices to sell
for profit or to use in crimes ranging from extortion to murder.
The new interest in radiological material by smugglers and
criminal networks complicates an already difficult task confronting
governments: how to stop terrorists from obtaining any of the tens
of thousands of powerful radiological sources around the world that
are currently in private hands or have simply been discarded. In
Georgia and other unstable corners of the world, radioactive
materials are turning up on black markets alongside more traditional
contraband, such as drugs or Kalashnikov rifles.
They are a currency of the global gray zone, a dangerous mixture
of failed states, porous borders and weak law enforcement, where the
tools of terrorism are bought and sold.
Crude but
Effective
The involvement of professional smugglers and criminals only
increases the odds that some of the radiological materials will end
up in the hands of terrorists, U.S. experts say. Already, the sheer
volume of such materials in circulation has prompted scientists at
the Los Alamos National Laboratory to conclude, in a study released
in September, that a dirty bomb "attack somewhere in the world is
overdue."
So serious is the threat that both the Bush administration and
the International Atomic Energy Agency have launched major
initiatives within the past 18 months to find and lock up abandoned
radiological material across the globe. At the Energy Department,
Secretary Spencer Abraham (news
- web
sites) has made preventing a dirty-bomb threat a top priority,
on a par with long-established programs to secure nuclear stockpiles
in the former Soviet Union.
A dirty bomb, or "radiological dispersion device" in the jargon
of defense experts, is not a nuclear weapon but rather a crude
device that uses conventional explosives or other means to spread
radiation over a wide area. Compared to true nuclear weapons or even
to biological or chemical weapons, they are technologically simple,
and well within the grasp of international terrorist groups, nuclear
experts say.
Documents seized from training camps in Afghanistan (news
- web
sites) two years ago by U.S. forces showed that al Qaeda leaders
there planned to build a dirty bomb and may have begun gathering
materials for one. Iraq (news
- web
sites), which struggled in vain for a decade to master the
complexities of a nuclear weapon, built and tested a dirty bomb in
the 1980s before abandoning the program on the grounds that it was
ineffective against military targets, according to U.N. weapons
inspectors.
Such a bomb would likely unleash panic and trigger economic and
social upheavals. Even a moderately sized dirty bomb exploded in a
modern city could contaminate large swaths of real estate with
radiation, rendering some areas uninhabitable for months or
years.
Last year, the Federation of American Scientists conducted a
computer simulation to determine the impact of exploding less than
two ounces of cesium-137, about 3,500 curies, in the heart of
Manhattan. (A curie is a unit used to measure radioactivity. Experts
say that a device of only a few dozen curies could make an effective
bomb.) In the simulation, fine cesium particles spread across an
area covering 60 square blocks. Cleanup and relocation following the
blast would take years to complete and cost tens of billions of
dollars, the study found.
Whether the radiation from such a blast would cause deaths or
injuries is a subject of renewed debate. A view long held by
radiation experts was that the human toll would be minimal; any
deaths and injuries would be those caused by the blast effects of
the explosion itself.
Now scientists aren't so sure. A new analysis, drawn from medical
studies of radiation accidents, sees a significant health threat in
the clouds of radioactive dust thrown up by a dirty-bomb explosion.
The diluted radioactivity in those dust clouds would probably be too
weak to cause serious harm. But, according to a new National Defense
University analysis expected to be released next month, people near
the blast site could suffer serious internal injuries from highly
radioactive particles that enter the body through the nose and mouth
and lodge in sensitive tissues. The severity of the injuries would
depend on the type of radioactive material used, how it is spread,
and how quickly the victims can be treated.
"If the particles are in a respirable form, they can do
considerable damage -- to the lungs, to the digestive system, to the
immune system," said Peter Zimmerman, chairman of the panel that
produced the study. "Overall, the effects could be much worse than
many of us previously thought."
Guerrilla
Smugglers
Dozens of smuggling routes for nuclear and radiological materials
have been charted over the past decade, but since 1999 a clear
favorite has emerged. Judging from cases reported to police, nuclear
traffickers have discovered abundant opportunity in Europe's
southeastern flank: the Black Sea and Caucasus states that have long
served as a crossroads linking Europe, the Middle East and Asia.
Topping the list is Georgia, the former Soviet republic where
huge crowds of demonstrators recently forced President Eduard
Shevardnadze to resign. The small nation of 5 million suffers from
porous borders, official corruption and rampant smuggling, problems
exacerbated by three ethnic rebellions -- in the provinces of
Abkhazia and South Ossetia in the north, and Adzharia in the south
-- and regular incursions by guerrillas in the eastern region
bordering Chechnya (news
- web
sites). In the conflict zones, trafficking in contraband has
gone from a sideline trade to a thriving industry that supports tens
of thousands of people, including, by some accounts, leaders of the
rebel movements.
"Today, it's smuggling that keeps the separatist movements
alive," said Aleko Kupatadze, a black-market specialist at the
Transnational Crime and Corruption Center in Tbilisi. "Many of the
guerrillas are really professional criminals who sometimes even
switch sides. The violence you see has less to do with ethnic
conflict than with disagreements over how the spoils are
divided."
Radioactive materials are now caught up in the illicit trade.
Georgia has been a dumping ground for Soviet-era radioactive
hardware and waste, some of it extraordinarily lethal. Abandoned
radioactive devices are found regularly in Georgia's rugged hills,
often after a villager turns up with severe radiation burns. Two
years ago this month, three woodcutters in northern Georgia nearly
died of radiation injuries after stumbling across a Soviet-built
generator powered by strontium with a radioactivity level of 40,000
curies. Nine such devices have been found in Georgia since the
mid-1990s, and as many as three more are feared to be still
missing.
"We inherited chaos. Radiological equipment has turned up in
garbage dumps, even in sewage," said Dato Bakradze, director of
international security and conflict management for Georgia's
National Security Council. The possibility that Georgian terrorists
or separatists might obtain one of the devices, he said, poses a
"direct physical danger to our own country."
Since the early 1990s, Georgian police have been intercepting
radioactive flotsam from amateur sellers hoping to profit from their
discoveries. Lately, the materials offered for sale have become more
sophisticated, and so have the traffickers.
At least three times since 1999, officials have discovered
kilogram-quantity caches of uranium in vehicles leaving or entering
Georgia. In the most recent case, on June 26, just over a pound of
uranium was seized at the Georgia-Armenia border by guards armed
with U.S.-supplied radiation detectors, according to Georgian
security officials. Tests to determine the origin and enrichment
level of the uranium were carried out with the help of U.S. Energy
Department officials. The agency has declined to release the
results. Georgian officials say they believe the material originated
in Russia and was being transported through Georgia for resale in
Iran.
The smuggling incident uncovered on May 31 in Georgia's capital
appears to have been bolder still. If the plan had unfolded as
intended, the radioactive materials would have moved by public train
through the heart of the country's most populous city, into the
troubled Adzharia province, a center of ethnic clashes and
long-simmering hostility toward Georgia's central government.
Makeria, 33, the taxi driver, has told police he knows almost
nothing about the origins or destination of the deadly cargo. In
fact, he may not have realized the contents were radioactive,
despite warning labels written in English and Russian, said Tamaz
Alania, chief of the criminal division of Georgia's Internal Affairs
Ministry.
"It is at least possible that Makeria did not know," Alania said
in an interview. "He seemed confused and nervous when we first
questioned him. And when we explained what was in the boxes he
became much more nervous."
Makeria told police he picked up the unusually heavy green
cartons from Giorgi Samkhakiuli, 29, an acquaintance of his
father-in-law, who asked him to keep the boxes at his home in
Adzharia until someone else came to pick them up. But Samkhakiuli, a
man described by police as having a history of drug offenses,
vanished after the smuggling plot was foiled. Investigators continue
to pursue leads, but the search for others appears to have
stalled.
Police have learned that the larger of the two radiological
elements, a capsule of powdery cesium, was manufactured in the
Soviet Union in the 1970s for industrial use. While the cesium has
lost more than half of its original potency, it still contains
enough radioactivity to seriously injure or kill, investigators
said. Police were baffled about the possible origin of the mustard
gas substance, which was still being analyzed.
Where and how the smuggled materials were to be used, police can
only guess. But those responsible went out of their way to collect
and package three radioactive materials with no known uses other
than to terrorize or kill, said Malkhaz Salakaia, the investigations
director at Georgia's Ministry of State Security.
"At this point we have to assume there are other people behind
Samkhakiuli," Salakaia said. "And we cannot exclude that a criminal
act was envisioned."
Iridium for Ransom
The radiological materials coveted by criminal groups are not
found only in former Soviet states. Tens of thousands of powerful
radioactive devices are currently in use across a wide range of
industries, from medicine to metallurgy to mining. Some of them,
because of their size, potency and availability, have become popular
targets for thieves -- and a nightmare for counterterrorism
experts.
One such device is known as a "well-logger," an instrument used
by energy companies and geologists to search for underground oil
fields. In well-logging, a powerful capsule of radioactive metal --
usually americium, iridium or strontium -- is lowered into a well
shaft to probe for oil deposits, using beams of neutron and gamma
radiation that penetrate dense rock. Then the radiation is measured
to look for evidence of oil beneath the rocks. When not in use, the
core is kept in a shielded canister the size of a small beer
keg.
Well-loggers don't pack enormous amounts of radiation. But what
they carry is dangerous.
"It's a neutron source," said Abel Gonzales, the radiation safety
chief for the International Atomic Energy Agency, the U.N. nuclear
watchdog agency, referring to the type of deep-penetrating,
tissue-destroying radiation emitted by well-loggers. If a dirty bomb
is the objective, he said, "you could make something very nasty with
that."
They also are easy to obtain. Tens of thousands of well-loggers
are currently in use around the world, often in remote areas where
they are liable to be stolen or lost.
One particularly worrisome criminal plot that recently came to
light involved the theft of five iridium devices in Ecuador by a
criminal gang that demanded -- and received -- thousands of dollars
in payments for their return. It was the first known case of
successful blackmail involving radiological material, and U.S. and
U.N. experts fear the pattern could be repeated.
In a carefully planned, nighttime burglary Dec. 9, thieves broke
into a storage shed in Quininde, in the coastal province of
Esmeraldas, to steal the devices, which were owned by the firm
Interinspec, according to accounts by investigators at the U.N.
nuclear watchdog agency and Ecuador's Atomic Energy Commission. One
of the thieves knew precisely where the instruments were kept and
how much they were worth. He was a former employee who had been
recently fired in a job dispute, Ecuadoran officials said.
Within days, the company received a ransom demand, and despite
protests from government investigators, it decided to pay. Officials
familiar with the case say the firm's top manager agreed to a price
of $1,000 for each of the five devices. "He thought this was the
best way to take control of the five lost sources," said Marco Bravo
Salvador, technical director of the Ecuadoran commission.
The thieves, however, returned only three of the well-loggers,
apparently deciding to keep the other two. Meanwhile, the company
lost a sixth source in January when it fell from a boat into
Ecuador's Quininde River. A seventh device went missing when a work
crew accidentally left it behind after finishing a project in a
remote jungle location.
After a massive search involving hundreds of army troops, the
sources lost in the jungle and river were recovered. The two others,
presumably still in the hands of bandits, remain unaccounted
for.
Another recent theft, viewed by U.S. and U.N. officials as
especially grave, occurred in December when a large well-logger was
stolen from a truck in Nigeria. The owner of the device was
Halliburton Co., based in Houston, which conducted its own search
for several weeks before notifying the U.N. nuclear watchdog of the
loss.
The device reportedly was stolen while being hauled through the
oil-rich Niger Delta, between the cities of Warri and Port Harcourt.
Initially, the truck driver told police that someone swiped the
instrument from his vehicle when he stopped at a roadside motel for
a nap. Later, investigators began to find discrepancies in the
driver's story.
"The hotel story didn't check out," said one official involved in
the investigation, who spoke on condition that his name not be used.
"The suspicion now is that the driver took it," apparently as part
of a plot involving accomplices. The thief was apparently
knowledgeable about such well-loggers because, out of several
devices on the truck, he singled out the most powerful one, the
official said.
Months of searches using radiation detectors turned up no trace
of the missing well-logger. Then, two months ago, investigators got
a break. A well-logger discovered in a private scrap yard in
September turned out to be the same one that was stolen nine months
earlier. The scrap yard was in Germany, more than 3,200 miles from
the Niger Delta.